- 1774-1784 No permanent minister
- 1784-1811 William Sorey
- 1811-1839 Samuel Brown
- 1839-1843 George Norris
- 1843 Evan Forbe
- 1843-1846 Pritchard Jordan
- 1846-1853 Lemuel Sanderlin
- 1853-1857 Abner Perry
- 1853 Thomas Bayfield
- 1858 Richard H. Baylor
- no pastor during Civil War years
- 1859 -1861 William D. Pritchard
- Aug. 1865–1866 William D. Pritchard
- 1867-1890 Nathan M. Munden
- 1891 - 2/1892 C. W. Matthews
- June 1892 J. M. Dunaway
- 1893 J. D. Berry
- 1894 Nathan M. Munden
- 1904 L. C. Brickhouse
- Ambrose W. Burfoot
- 1906-09? William E. Lankford
- Paulette
- 1915 Sam N. Hurst
- 1919 George W. Cox
- 1921 George W. Sawyer
- 1923-1935 Henry B. Cole
- 1936-1937 Mott A. Cumby
- 1938-1951 Ralph W. Mapp
- 1952-1956 Wade G. Harding
- 1956-1961 David G. Costas
- 1961-1964 Gary B. Thompson
- 1964-1981 Ralph L. Horn
- 1981-1982 Melvin Hughes
- 1989-1990 Steve Wiseman
- 1991-1994 Roscoe Musselwhite
- 1995-1996 Otis Colston
- 6/96-9/03 Michael C. Jones
- 8/04-8/14 Greg Hammer
- 2008 Bill Russo (Associate Minister)
- 9/2015- Dr. Lynn Hardaway